Super fun to listen to!

Currently my favorite paranormal podcast out there…I really enjoy listening to these guys share their knowledge in a fun and interesting manner. Keep doing the good work🤘🛸👽🍄🦎

Sophomoric wanna be’s

Mike and Matteo blend hilarity and the pursuit of the truth all at the same time. If I want to laugh and learn, I go to this podcast. These boys are good medicine. I emailed them once and they sent back a loving response. These guys are legit and their merch looks awesome. Thanks, gents!

They sound clueless about most the most of the junk they cover and it’s always overdone by 20 other podcasts before they butcher the topic like missing 411 and skinwalker ranch the stardust episode could have been way better they should have not bothered. I’ve listened to this show on and off and it’s went to trash. No way is the rating actually true with mostly generic 5 star reviews.

I’ve been listening to the podcast at work and it really helps make the shift go by faster!

I’ve listened to these dudes since day 1. Stumbled on em and loved em ever since. Interesting takes on the oddest abnormalities! Spark some of that devil lettuce and give it a listen! ✌🏻

I just started listening about 2 weeks ago and I’m on episode 53 and this show is simply the best, I love what you guys talk about.

My daily listen during a 10 hour shift, these two bring the best of the weird. Love the show, still waiting for a chuthulu mythos show!!!!! (Update) still love the show, but the trump binding spell was stupid. I use these podcasts to escape the for awhile, now politics is invading my paranormal podcasts. Uhh, hope it doesn’t go on.

I absolutely love this pod and the hosts. I’ve been listening for years and I’m actually ashamed I havnt left a review sooner! Oooppie poopies. You guys make me laugh and I just appreciate how genuine you guys are! Thanks for bringing the bright vibes 🖖🏻✨

Love how they have a mix of facts with all the jokes they make and how they don’t just blindly accept everything as a fact and question if it is actually true. Also the deer story is amazing and I listen to it at least once a week.

The truth drips from lips that simultaneously spills jokes. The tips of smiles rise higher for the soul to cope. We are here but where, we don’t know. We are us but who we don’t know. Lift up those who seek meaning, however bleakly leaning, and feel the absurdity boil to burst as siren laughter that is playfully piercing the ears of those willfully listening. What is it to cast yourself to the unknown? What is it to cast unknowingly? At the end of the line when you have been reeled from the depths, You will look back and ask, “What Cast?”

This was the first podcast I ever started listening too and it is still my very favorite. It’s hard to find another pair of gents that do it like these two. Don’t take the topics too serious but still give good information, would love to get some some more interview episodes here and there

Updating my review for the May raffle, I hope it counts! Still five stars for their charm. Love these guys and their ability to get me totally creeped out and then laugh my ass off.

Mike and Mateo are a perfect pair. They have great chemistry, do good research, have open minds but skeptical when it calls for it. These guys go off on some of the best tangents that make the show incapable of being the same old topics. Also love the holiday and anniversary episodes. Have listened to the back catalog twice already and look forward to every new episode!

Great job gentlemen. This podcast is a great addition to anyone interested in paranormal, etc... stuff.

By far one of the most creative interesting and entertaining podcast out there! Personalities and topics always makes listening to the shows something to look forward to!

I like these guys and their topics. Sometimes, they go a little off track, but for the most part it’s interesting and sparks a lot of personal questions and investigations of my own. Realizing this isn’t their full time job, they seem to put a lot of genuine good effort into each episode and I always come out on the other side learning something.

I love this podcast it always makes me laugh! The Halloween show was hilarious!

This podcast is GREAT! I’ve been finding more and more paranormal/conspiracy podcasts and often get disappointed but this one has not let me down! I just found it 2 days ago and have already listened to 13 of them! :) A LOL of information that isn’t in other ones on the same topics, great background, very thorough and hilarious! Love it! I’ve fallen in love with Mike’s brain and voice, I know he’s taken and I’m a lesbian but I’m completely smitten ;) BTW I DO think he Montauk Monster is a raccoon, I found other pics... totally a raccoon! Haha please cover Project Blue Beam and the fake apocalypse sometime?

Just stumbled onto this podcast a week ago and can’t stop listening to it. These guys are hilarious. Mike’s long winded, in depth side tangents make me laugh so hard if I had balls I’d be pissing out of em. They are the right amount of dirty humored and genuinely thoughtful dudes. Not to mention they have very chill story telling voices. Yes you too Mateo, even if no one creepily imitated your voice. And bustin does indeed make you feel good.

Listened to my first show, it was on King Solomon. The hosts have great chemistry and are engaging. Just wish they’d dive a bit deeper into subject material, how can you not mention the link between Solomon and Bob Marley ( hint Haile Selassi), or that Menelik who was mentioned is also thought to be the son of Solomon and Sheba? A little disappointing as a little more research would have made for a great fantastic show.

Love this podcast, the guys are great! However, what is going on in episode 300?! It’s seems as the show has gone from conspiracies and paranormal to Fictional SciFi.

You guys are awesome I laugh and get creeped out! You two sound like my friends and I do when. We’re sitting around talking. Love it Keep it up

These guys have good information and fun theories. Most importantly, they don’t annoy me AT ALL which is phenomenally easy to do. Highly recommended.

You guys are the best! Love your show and keep up the great work!

Been listening for a long time. Keep up the great work

Found this kinda late, but I will burn through all the episodes. I have probably listened to almost 30 episodes in a week. Making the long boring work days go by much quicker. Keep up the great work guys.

I am a pretty cynical kind of gal and it's not easy to get a silent smile from me, let alone a genuine *lol*. I don't know what it says about me but somehow these guys pull it off like all the time. Especially during the most macabre subjects 👾👽☠️

Great talk, without talking itself too seriously.

Please see title.

Ok, Maybe that’s an inaccurate title. Mike and Matteo are classy dudes who discuss the mysteries of life, without the use of excessive sound effects. Aliens, Cryptids, Demons, Historic Creepiness, and more, this show has a diverse lineup- which keeps you on your toes. I love this show because they balance all the spook with a great sense of humor, which means I can still sleep at night. Thanks a bunch you guys and keep it up!

One of fave podcasts never disappoint with these guys highly recommended if you’re into the phenomenon n UFOs. Great job guys keep it up.👍👍👍

Fun show to listen to and I like the subjects to listen to at work. Keep it up

Hey Guys! I just want to say I love your guys podcasts I been listening to you guys for about 3 years now! I caught up on all the old episodes too. Im always looking forward to your next episoded. Anyways.. I always recommend you guys to my friends and family when I get the chance! Do you think you guys can do a episode on legends and conspiracies about the "dark web" all the crazy s@&$ that happens there? Thank you for awesome entertainment guys! Have a great day! -Gabriel

“The What Cast” is perfection! Mike and Mateo are fantastic hosts, whose shrewd commentary is always informative and immensely entertaining. Their dark senses of humor, and witty ramblings, make the show feel as if you’re sitting around a bonfire, amongst friends, engaging in harmless tomfoolery, and telling creepy stories. The show covers a range of well-researched topics including the paranormal, aliens, and folkloric mysteries. (Jokes aside, go ahead and invest in a nightlight). I couldn’t recommend “The What Cast” more! Thank you guys for the top-notch content and sleepless nights!

The What Cast has ruined every other podcast. The bar is set too high. Thanks 🙄

I've been trying out every podcast relative to this genre that I can find, and most aren't making the cut. The What Cast has made the cut. Great stuff.

Mike and Mateo are funny, irreverent, and entertaining. They cover the usual weird things, along with some hidden treasures of the paranormal.

These guys are hilarious! There has been so many frustrating days at work but these guys keep me laughing. I love how dedicated they are to this podcast and I am never disappointed. Great job!

New listener and I already love it. You guys are great. I dig the chemistry, the topics, the opinions. It’s super listenable and entertaining and really makes you feel like you’re part of the conversation. Keep it up.

These guys do a great job of presenting information about very little known mysteries without recycling the same subjects in all the tv shows. They are light hearted funny and better than any of the paranormal tv shows by far.

These guys have a laid back approach that makes the show flow really well. It feels like I’m talking with friends except I learn something. When its over, I’m sad :(

You know those two buddies you had in high school that would be stoned all the time and constantly doing things that made you laugh? These are those two guys. Sit back relax and enjoy. They have shows that have a lot of really good and cool information on myths and legends, but it is presented as if Bill and Ted personally wrote every episode. Listen to this show and tell everyone you know about it!! Start at the first show, by 200 you'll be rewarded with the best two-part episode in the history of garage podcasts!

Great Podcast! Lots of great episodes. The montauk project was my favorite one. The synchronicity one too. The weird is brought on this podcast

They are really cool guys who always help me get through my work week! I've reccomended this podcast to a number of my co-workers and they've really enjoyed it. I really enjoy the broad topics they cover.

I love this podcast. The topics are what I'm interested in and while it's laid back it's like talking to friends that are funnier than you are.

I'd love to write a nasty review just to hear Mateo freak out again, but I can't, because the what cast really is my favorite. Their "research" is in the show notes people!!! who even bothers to look that crap up anyway? But seriously, I love the show. Great topics, not the same old beat to death paranormal crap and it's friggen hilarious. The dog with a mans head still cracks me up..lol. I wanted to say that I appreciate the time and RESEARCH you guys do, and that I really do look forward to your shows every week.

two great dudes discussing what's important to us

I absolutely love this podcast! Highly entertaining, interesting, and hilarious. I have yet to listen to an episode that I haven't liked. Keep up the great work, fellas!