I found this pod cast through my dad and I’ve always been interested in true crime but I never really listened to it. So when I found this podcast I can’t stop listening to it! It’s very entertaining podcast I love how she does this with her husband.

I just love you guys. Keep up the good work ❤️

Hi again Payton and Garrett! I wanted to let you guys know I appreciate everything you both do for us listeners! I’ve finally finished all of murder with my husband and into the dark including the bonus episodes! I’m kinda sad 🤣 now I have to wait instead of being able to binge it😭. I loved the live showed by the way! A Garrett I definitely enjoyed the switch up on you reeling the story u did great! I love you both as a couple and podcast together and Payton I loveee McDonald’s too 🤣. Thanks again for everything. With love Michelle P.S. oh and my favorite episode was the torso murder because it took place where I use to live in New Jersey so that was very interesting.

Are my favorite murder couple! They have such a refreshing rapport and original concept to true crime. I rarely hear something I haven't already (and I follow a lot of true crime). Their story-telling is addicting and interesting.

I found your podcast through another that I love but ran through all the episodes & find that they don’t put many out! However they mentioned yours and it sounded interesting (true crime loving wife, husband who isn’t really interested in it, and listening to you together). I opened it up and scrolled the episodes & found one that was local that I helped in the search for and listened and subscribed immediately! And while we all love Garrett & his funny asides.. “CAMERAS!” I adore Payton & the work she puts in to research the cases- giving the victims voices and keeping cases fresh for the missing! That passion is so beautiful, so consider me a member of the Payton fan club!! (You’re so young but even if you don’t feel it.. and your work blows me away!) This podcast is great true crime, without being gratuitous, and the husband & wife and their combo is just great. Love you guys! Plus you give us SO much content!! Thank you!!

I’m loving your hooks at the beginning and the way that they really hooked me into this new story but sometimes they give away a bit too much information and then I’m just sitting there wondering when will more action come in But over all, I LOVE IT!!!

I used to hate Monday’s now I patiently be waiting every Monday for a new episode.

You guys are amazing. You guys always help me get through everything like trying to sleep, I listen to you guys it helps me fall asleep, better you guys and it helps me get through the day and you guys always have the biggest sense of humor so thank you for always being there

My daughter introduced me to your podcast when we were driving to Wyoming and I just love your show I now listen to it while I’m at the pool and crocheting 🥰

I love the pod cart you do alone and the one you and your husband do together. I love love the way your husband gasps at the lack of investigation from authorities. I’m right there with ya. You guys make a great team

It’s the greed for me. To claim you wouldn’t be able to do this podcast without the ads is ridiculous especially when you somehow managed to do it with no advertising before additionally to have subscriptions on top of advertisements is giving let’s get rich off the trauma and grief of others and keep insisting that we NEED the advertisement money.

I work Construction, so around 10 hrs a day. And I can tell you that more then half you can find we listening to this pod. it really makes the hard work day fun!

I absolutely love this podcast. The way Payton tells the stories pulls me in and keeps me engaged like no other true crime podcast I’ve listened to (and I’ve listened to a lottt. I listen to one almost every night while falling asleep). They truly speak about the cases and victims with so much care. MWMH has become my new go-to show!

I really love how you get through the story without a ton of banter but yet I can still get a feel for your personalities. Hands down my favorite podcast and the only one I’m a subscriber for. Your empathy for the victims and their loved ones is unmatched! Going to start the YouTube route before long but I hate having to wait til I get home to listen lol

I got tired of the 10 seconds at the start of every episode, which is more like 5-10 minutes of talking about random stuff then that’s all the comments will be about instead of the actual case. You can tell Garett doesn’t care or want to be there, he asks the most basic questions and doesn’t give much of a reaction. I don’t get the “I love it, I hate it” tagline it feels disrespectful to me towards the families, Garrett clearly doesn’t hate it enough to let it be their main source of income since I never hear about him having a job

I discover this podcast a few years ago. Have been totally obsessed since then.The detail,commutation between each other basically the over all atmosphere is incredible.I listen daily to all their media. They help my work day go by so quickly .”5” stars all the way !

Hey May 25, 2025- you reported your birthday was today. You were born 5/25/1924. Had to listen twice to make sure. Got a great laugh out of that! 🤩😎🤣 LOVE THIS PODCAST! So entertaining!!!

New listener! Binging all the episodes and I. CAN’T. STOP! Truly one of the best True Crime Podcast out there! Keep the coming!

Love this podcast. Heard about yall from a friend who listens and I was hooked. Binged every single episode. Thank you so much for doing what yall do. Much love!

This podcast is tolerable filler while you wait for your preferred ones to drop episodes. I’m not sure if it’s a schtick or not but the hosts act super ditzy, constantly misusing and mispronouncing words and getting confused over basics. I can see that they try and are putting real work in, but don’t expect to hear any revelatory thoughts and opinions from great minds here and prepare to be underwhelmed if you like smart, thoughtful, funny, educated commentary.

I listen for background noise at work. Some stories are good others a little boring. I know some of the cases they gave featured and she is wrong with some details. He is a narcissist and she comes across uneducated. She mispronounces a lot of words and when she goes off script she has trouble talking. I am tired of his pickleball and golf or how he is getting “jacked”. Is it me or is he is going to do everything and never does any of them. No marathon, no iron man. He is boring and they seem just interested in talking about money making stuff for the show.

Garrett, the husband, is extremely unintelligent, which makes this a very hard listen. He’s constantly asking stupid questions, reiterating things that Payton has already said, and interrupting her. I used to really like this podcast, but it’s clear that there’s something lacking.

This is my go to podcast and I cannot get through the week without listening. Best of the best!

I have listened to almost every episode. Garrett’s comments always make me laugh. Love Payton’s voice and story telling.

I do love them but her sources are really unreliable ; a lot of .com websites. Also pronunciation of words ex- Catholicism was pronounced Catholic-ism I am not trying to be to hard they give a good story but when you are storytellers you should say the words right or at least attempt to look it up. Peyton has a great voice

I just found MWMH and I’m really enjoying it. I’m surprised at how many cases I’ve listened to so far that I hadn’t heard about in other podcasts. Very good story telling!

I’ve been listening to their podcast since December of 2022 and it’s been my favorite ever since. I love how funny and entertaining you guys are and how you can make true crime so palatable if that makes sense. Garrett always cracks me up and I love his hot takes. I’m especially grateful for this podcast on my long drives to and from work. Truly the only podcast I haven’t gotten sick of and I doubt I ever will! Keep up the great work (also Peyton and I share the same bday, November 25th, so it’s meant to be!)

I am OBSESSED with your podcast! Give Garrett more than 10 seconds please! He cracks me up!!

Ever since I found this podcast, I’ve stopped listening to all the others—nothing else even comes close. You guys are so real, relatable, and hilarious. Cannot recommend enough!

I have grown to love this podcast so much. I love listening to Garrett’s “10 seconds,” and I love how raw and real Payton is. I am a subscriber and I definitely will continue to support these two.

I love you guys. I first saw your pod on a billboard in Lehi, UT. I love the vivid storytelling!

Excellent podcast and I enjoy Garrett’s input

Garett interrupts Payton way too much . Just chill dude lol. Let her finish the stories.

Hey guys! Amazing podcast, I love the detail you guys go into, and how much fun you have! I’ve started my own podcast and could use some tips on how to grow an audience, the shows name is “The Mad Hatters, a history of haberdashery.

I look forward to listening to MWMH every week. I wish there were more episodes.

I truly love your guy’s podcast. It is entertaining and I like how you respect the victims in each case. I love the whole 10 seconds and I do not care if it is longer because if it really bothers you then just skip it. I listen to it as I work and I always try to figure out who it is as you go. To people thinking about listening, try it. I love it. Listen to all of there podcasts because they are all great. Shout out to Payton for her awesome research. Also, Garret please stay because you help make the podcast great. I love your questions because they help me understand at times when I get confused or hear it wrong. The haters just don’t get it.

I love y’all so much. I listen to y’all almost everyday. DO NOT LISTEN TO THE KARENS IN THE REVIEWS!!!! Keep doing what you’re doing love yallll

I’ve listened for over a year or two…I love the crimes, it’s so interesting to hear of crimes that’s aren’t so well known. There are some good and some bad, overall I no longer follow the show. Pros: Peyton is always so well prepared, her story is well planned, she knows her stuff. I like some of the husband wife banter, the quick wit back and forth. They seem to get along well, but I’ve noticed over time Peyton seems more frustrated, less patient. Cons: Garett interrupting(!!!!!!) Peyton ALL the time. Omg please let her finish before cutting her off. The thing that made me officially unsubscribe were the ads…why the heck do the ads have to cut off the story mid sentence? Overall between Garett and the ads interrupting the story, I couldn’t do it anymore.

I listen to this podcast all the time! I am obsessed!

Love the podcast. Got a friend from work hooked on it also

OK, can I just say these reviews are like so annoying stop being a Karen let them do everything into their podcast. No one said that you have to watch it. So stop complaining someone doesn’t have to change their podcast just because you don’t like it. Keep in entertaining with the positive and good reviews. Anyway, I love the podcast very much. It’s so good and I think it’s so funny. Garrett and Payton are really good people. I love how they respect victims . Love you guys.

This has become one of my favorite podcasts. I love how they tell the story without a lot of opinions. Very factually based show.

binged (ITD) got me into true crime and now MWMH is my fav podcast. live shows are always awesome and i really appreciate how clean the language is bc i can send it to everyone i know and not be worried about an explicit disclaimer lol

I enjoy listening to this duo ! Wish my husband would patiently listen to me tell the crazy stories too. They do have a few kinks namely I will say their ad insertion is really tough they don’t even have a pause we’re in the midst of talking about a death and the next word is an ad it’s jarring.

Listening to this podcast, especially on long bus rides back from football games, is definitely one of the best things I’ve ever done. Keep up the good work!!

I was enjoying the podcast until an offensive comment was made in episode 259 regarding two relatives potentially being involved in an incestuous relationship. Garrett remarked, “We’ve got to be in Alabama or something.” I currently live in Florida but am a former Alabamian. That comment showed his ignorance and willingness to perpetuate a negative stereotype of people who live in the South. I will not support anyone who would readily share negative stereotypes of any group, race, or religion.

I’m not a huge podcast person, but when I tell you, this is the only podcast I listen to that is the gods honest truth. I’ve been listening to them for a few years now and every episode I’m hooked!!❤️🫶

Love this podcast! Garrett’s commentary honestly makes me crack up sometimes especially when it’s a little outlandish and Peyton’s is just like uhm, okay. But, recently the episodes have gotten a little short. Peyton seems really tired. Maybe she is going through something. Make sure you’re prioritizing your mental health girl! 🩵

The podcast is good but please more episodes without Garrett. He’s always confused and asks questions with obvious answers that if he were paying attention he would already know

I absolutely love you guys!! My merch came yesterday and I’m BEYOND HAPPY!!! It’s perfect and it fits perfectly 💕